Lagatar24.com
Language : HINDI
  • Home
  • Jharkhand
  • Bihar
  • National & World
  • Business
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Career
  • Tech – Gyan
  • Opinion
Thursday, 19 November, 2026
Lagatar24.com
  • Home
  • Jharkhand
  • Bihar
  • National & World
  • Business
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Career
  • Tech – Gyan
  • Opinion
Lagatar24.com
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Jharkhand
  • Bihar
  • National & World
  • Business
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Career
  • Tech – Gyan
  • Opinion
Home Opinion

Bilkis Bano Case: Liberty Cannot Be Reduced to a Formula

Lagatar News by Lagatar News
November 19, 2026
in Opinion
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A K Rashidi

The Supreme Court’s October 28, 2026 order suspending the life sentences of two convicts in the Bilkis Bano gang-rape and murder case raises a question larger than the bail of two prisoners. It asks how judicial discretion should be exercised when individual liberty meets the gravity of an atrocity, the dignity and safety of a survivor, and public confidence in the rule of law.

What the Order Does and Does Not Do

A Bench of Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale suspended the sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya and granted them bail on conditions to be fixed by the trial court. The Court noted over 17 years of incarceration, a severe handicap affecting one of them, and unresolved issues of fact and law in their appeals. Their convictions stand and the appeals are pending.

I begin with an important qualification. Suspension of sentence is not executive remission, and bail is not acquittal. The order must be judged on its own legal footing. But the fact that the power is judicial does not put its exercise beyond scrutiny. In a case with this history, the public is entitled to know not only what the Court ordered but why.

The History Behind the Order

Bilkis Bano was five months pregnant when she was gang-raped during the 2002 Gujarat violence, and seven members of her family, including her three-year-old daughter, were killed. The trial was moved to Maharashtra, where a special CBI court convicted 11 men in 2008 and sentenced them to life imprisonment. The Bombay High Court upheld the verdict on May 4, 2017.

In August 2022, the Gujarat government granted the 11 convicts remission. On January 8, 2024, the Supreme Court quashed those orders in Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India (2024 INSC 24), holding that Gujarat was not the “appropriate government” because the trial was held in Maharashtra. The convicts were directed to surrender.

That ruling reaffirmed that statutory power must be exercised by the authority the law entrusts with it. The 2026 order, however, concerns judicial suspension of sentence pending appeal. The two routes must not be confused, and the 2024 decision neither bars judicial bail nor validates it.

Liberty Is a Right, Suspension Needs Reasons

Article 21 does not stop protecting a person upon conviction. A convict is entitled to an effective appeal, and long incarceration, serious illness and delay in hearing can all matter. But suspending a life sentence is not an automatic result of time served. The conviction has been affirmed by the High Court, so the court must make a careful, case-specific assessment.

The gravity of the offence is not an absolute bar, but it cannot be treated as decoration either. The court must weigh the manner of the crime, each appellant’s role, the lower courts’ findings, the arguable grounds of appeal, the period and quality of custody, medical circumstances, the risk of absconding or intimidation, and the safety of the survivor and witnesses.

My difficulty is with the brevity of the publicly reported reasoning. “Issues of fact and law” is a phrase that fits almost every criminal appeal and does not explain why suspension suits this one. The Court need not decide the appeal at this stage, but it should name the main arguable issue or explain how the combined factors justify interim release.

Verifying the Seventeen Years

Where the length of custody is decisive, the calculation should be transparent and specific to each appellant. It should separate actual jail time, parole or furlough, the period outside prison under the 2022 remission, and the period after the 2024 surrender. A short custody chart backed by prison records would have made the reasoning clearer and avoided controversy.

Disability Must Be Assessed Individually

A court cannot be indifferent to disability, dignity or access to treatment. But the medical case should rest on current, reliable material, including whether treatment is possible in custody and why bail is necessary. One appellant’s condition cannot decide the other’s case, so identical relief needs reasons that are either individual or common to both.

The Survivor Must Not Become Invisible

Bilkis Bano is not merely a witness whose role ended with the trial. Her need for protection and the State’s duty to secure her dignity continue, and any change in the custody of those convicted of crimes against her bears directly on her security.

Press reports quote her as saying she was not heard before the order. Whether a mandatory hearing was denied is something the order-sheet and service record must establish, and I do not assert it as fact. The law distinguishes the victim’s right to be heard from a veto over the outcome, but her participation should not be treated as inconsequential. The Supreme Court stressed victims’ participatory rights in Jagjeet Singh v. Ashish Mishra (2022) 9 SCC 321, though its application to suspension of sentence must be analysed on the statute and procedure involved.

Release conditions should be practical and enforceable. They can include no-contact directions, a bar on approaching the survivor or witnesses, restrictions on entering specified areas, regular reporting, disclosure of residence and travel, and liberty to seek cancellation on breach.

A Warning from 2024

The 2024 judgment did not say these convicts could never get bail. Its lasting message is that the appearance of legality is not enough, and power must be exercised by the proper authority, for proper reasons and within legal limits. That applies equally to judicial power. The higher the stakes, the greater the need for clarity, not because public opinion should steer the courts, but because reasoned decisions are the best protection against arbitrariness.

What a Fuller Assessment Should Have Covered

  • The procedural route by which the appeals reached the Supreme Court
  • An appellant-wise, record-based custody chronology
  • Medical material on the disabled appellant and why custody-based treatment would not suffice
  • The main arguable issues in the appeals, without prejudging the merits
  • Whether the survivor had notice and a chance to raise safety concerns
  • Reasons for identical relief to both appellants if their circumstances differ
  • Protective conditions and an expedited hearing schedule, so interim release does not turn indefinite

Neither Reflexive Detention Nor Unexplained Release

It would be unsound to equate this judicial order with the executive remission quashed in 2024, and equally unsound to treat it as immune from criticism. The question is whether the recorded reasons show a careful balance of liberty, appellate fairness, the gravity of the crime, the survivor’s rights and public confidence.

The order may yet be sustained on the full record. But the reasoning made public is too compressed to answer the legitimate questions this extraordinary case raises. I do not attribute motives to the Bench or prejudge the appeals. My criticism is limited to the adequacy and transparency of the reasons.

Liberty must not be withheld by reflex, nor granted by shorthand. In a constitutional democracy, judicial discretion earns public trust through reasons, fairness and accountability.

Share76Tweet47
Previous Post

Hindu Janajagruti Samiti Slams ‘Ramayana’ Makers, Threatens Nationwide Protest If Part Two Is Not Changed

Next Post

Cyclone ‘Akvan’ to Begin Affecting Jharkhand From This Evening, Rain Alert in Several Districts

Related Posts

Delhi Police Personnel Stage Rare Protest Outside Headquarters: Is the Force Pushing Back Against Political Pressure?

November 3, 2026
Republic Day and Jharkhand’s Cultural Spirit: A Pledge to Water, Forest, and Land

Republic Day and Jharkhand’s Cultural Spirit: A Pledge to Water, Forest, and Land

January 26, 2026

Corruption Model from Chhattisgarh Replicated in Jharkhand Liquor Policy

January 2, 2026
Women Rally For Convicted Rapist Sengar, Arguments Trigger Nationwide Outrage

Women Rally For Convicted Rapist Sengar, Arguments Trigger Nationwide Outrage

December 29, 2025
Bihar Will Remember Prashant Kishor, Even If It Didn’t Vote For Him Today

Bihar Will Remember Prashant Kishor, Even If It Didn’t Vote For Him Today

November 17, 2025

Ethanol Adulteration and Profiteering Are a National Enterprise

September 15, 2025
Load More
  • About Editor
  • Advertise with us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

© 2024 Lagatar News (Lagatar24.com)

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Jharkhand
  • Bihar
  • National & World
  • Business
  • Health & Lifestyle
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Career
  • Tech – Gyan
  • Opinion

© 2024 Lagatar News (Lagatar24.com)